Exhibit P-1Case No. DWT-001
1.05 → 1.93
uses per 1,000 words
AI-era marketing words nearly doubled after ChatGPT
Counsel for the prosecution
The Court of Public Prose
Court is in session
Is the web's writing dying into one machine voice? Both sides will be heard.
Sound is a clerk's voice, about 14 seconds in all. Every line is captioned.
Evidence for the theory
18 of 18 exhibits
Evidence against the theory
19 of 19 exhibits
The jury is still out.
We don't argue for the theory or against it. We test it, case by case, and publish the evidence on both sides.
The court: Order, order.
The clerk: This court is now in session. Today, we hear the case of Dead Writing Theory.
The court: Counsel for the prosecution. Counsel for the defence. Present your evidence.
The court: The jury is still out.
§ IOpening statement
Right, let's get the housekeeping out of the way. We are the court reporter. That's it. We sit at the little desk at the side of the room, we take down every word, and we don't get a vote.
Counsel for neither side. Nobody's paying us to win, which, honestly, is a relief, because winning sounds exhausting.
What we do is simple. A claim walks in. We test it, case by case, with code that doesn't have opinions, and then we publish what came out. Both sides get their say. The verdicts get written down, even the awkward ones (especially the awkward ones). If you write copy for a living, or you pay people who do, this is your gallery. Take a seat. Mind the em dash jokes; we'll come to those.
§ IIThe exhibits
37 exhibits from 15 cases, entered as they came out of the studies. Any tally counts the evidence items below; it is not a measure of truth.
Evidence for the theory
1.05 → 1.93
uses per 1,000 words
Each of 147 company homepages compared with itself, 2019 to 2022 against 2023 to 2026. Up on 83 sites, down on 27.
Entered for the prosecution · ScriptGrain SGR-004
4.4×
7.1 → 31.3 uses per 100,000 words
Company homepages, 2023 to 2026 against 2019 to 2022.
Entered for the prosecution · ScriptGrain SGR-004
2023
first year
"Seamless", "unlock" and "streamline" passed "solutions", "world-class" and "click here".
Entered for the prosecution · ScriptGrain SGR-004
69%
of software homepages use an em dash (2023 to 2026)
Against 17% of banking and finance homepages. Software also carries the most AI-era vocabulary: 3.88 uses per 1,000 words, against 0.39 for insurers.
Entered for the prosecution · ScriptGrain SGR-004
24%
of corporate press releases, late 2024
537,413 corporate press releases, January 2022 to September 2024. A population-level estimate from word distributions, not a per-document detector.
Entered for the prosecution · Liang et al., Patterns 6(12), 2025 · third-party study
18%
of financial consumer complaints, late 2024
Roughly 18% of 687,241 consumer complaints. Also nearly 10% of job postings in small firms and 14% of UN press releases.
Entered for the prosecution · Liang et al., Patterns 6(12), 2025 · third-party study
2.1% → 29.4%
of sites, second half of 2022 → first half of 2025
Roughly 100k sites archived by Common Crawl, classified site by site. A preprint; on pre-ChatGPT sites the classifier flagged only 0.29%.
Entered for the prosecution · He et al., arXiv preprint 2605.00087, 2026 · third-party study
46.6%
of 10,000 how-to searches had one in the top 10
65.7% for the top 20 results. 78.8% of LLM-dominant sites have a clear financial incentive, against 55.8% of other sites.
Entered for the prosecution · He et al., arXiv preprint 2605.00087, 2026 · third-party study
50.9%
of new English articles primarily AI-generated, Q4 2025
49.6% against 50.4% human in Q1 2025. Vendor study: 55.4k Common Crawl articles, three commercial detectors averaged.
Entered for the prosecution · Paredes et al., Graphite research (Five Percent), 2026 · third-party study
10.7%
of the total similarity range, with one AI idea
8.9% with up to five AI ideas. 293 writers in a preregistered experiment; similarity measured with text embeddings.
Entered for the prosecution · Doshi and Hauser, Science Advances, 2024 · third-party study
28.0×
expected use of "delves" in 2024 PubMed abstracts
Expected from the 2021 to 2022 trend, across 15.1 million abstracts. "Underscores" 13.8×, "showcasing" 10.7×. 379 style words showed excess use in 2024.
Entered for the prosecution · Kobak et al., Science Advances 11(27), 2025 · third-party study
13.5%
of 2024 PubMed abstracts, a lower bound
From excess style words, not a detector. Below 5% to over 40% across fields, countries and journals; at least two times the size of the 2021 Covid literature.
Entered for the prosecution · Kobak et al., Science Advances 11(27), 2025 · third-party study
21 to 50%
less variance in writing complexity after LLM rewriting
GPT-3.5, Llama 3 70B and Gemini Pro polished 1,000 pre-ChatGPT Reddit and arXiv texts each. Meaning was kept: 87% of similarity scores above 0.95.
Entered for the prosecution · Sourati et al., Nature Human Behaviour, 2026 · third-party study
3 / 3
datasets with lower writing-complexity variance after ChatGPT
80,238 arXiv abstracts, 318,490 Reddit stories, 379,583 Patch news articles from 2018. AI use predicted later drops on Reddit and arXiv, not on Patch news.
Entered for the prosecution · Sourati et al., Nature Human Behaviour, 2026 · third-party study
22.5%
of computer science abstract sentences LLM-modified, September 2024
2.4% in November 2022, before ChatGPT. Introductions 19.6%. 1,121,912 papers; a population-level estimate, not a detector.
Entered for the prosecution · Liang et al., Nature Human Behaviour 9(12), 2025 · third-party study
44%
above expected use of "delve" in Science and Technology podcasts
About 44%, 13 to 18 months after ChatGPT's release. 737,083 hours from 824,634 podcast episodes, screened for unscripted speech.
Entered for the prosecution · Yakura et al., arXiv preprint (version 4, July 2026), 2026 · third-party study
74.2%
of 900,000 new English pages, April 2025
Ahrefs' own detector, one page per domain. Vendor study; no error rate published.
Entered for the prosecution · Law et al., Ahrefs blog, 2025 · third-party study
0.217
unspaced em dashes per 1,000 characters in 2025, up from 0.10 to 0.12 in 2021 to 2024
146,239 releases from 480 offices. 75.6% of 262 offices increased their use; hyphens stayed near 2.7 per 1,000, so it was not conversion. Releases with one rose from about 13% to 24.8%.
Entered for the prosecution · Czuma, arXiv preprint (preregistered on OSF), 2026 · third-party study
Evidence against the theory
0.45 → 1.29
uses per 1,000 words, 2012 to 2019
AI-era vocabulary was already climbing three years before ChatGPT launched.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-004
3% → 27%
of homepages, 2000 to 2022
38% by 2026. The rise after ChatGPT continues a line that started in 2000.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-004
0.16 → 0.11
AI-style sentence shapes per 1,000 words
"Not X but Y", reflexive lists of three, "furthermore": no increase on company homepages after ChatGPT.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-004
3.7×
as many AI-isms as news, pre-ChatGPT
1.61 against 0.44 uses per 1,000 words in pages from 2021 and earlier.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-007
2.07
per 1,000 words in pre-1928 speeches
Sermons and religion 1.94; UK news 0.45.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-007
40 / 43
more common in 2019 than 1980
Google Books. "Transformative" rose 31 times between 1980 and 2019.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-007
3 / 600
Nigerian news pages used "delve" (2021)
1 of 600 Kenyan, 0 of 1,000 UK and US. Rare everywhere; the difference was within chance.
Entered for the defence · ScriptGrain SGR-007
214.45 → 254.65
MTLD lexical diversity, 2018 → 2024
Two samples of roughly 30,000 news articles each. Machine-style words did rise, from 0.230% to 0.347% of words, but the homogenisation did not show.
Entered for the defence · Fitterer et al., Proceedings of ACL, Student Research Workshop, 2025 · third-party study
0.00110
change in MATTR lexical diversity, 2018 → 2024
Against within-year variation of 0.00109 (MATTR 0.88011 → 0.88121). Maas moved from 0.01469 to 0.01482, a difference of 0.00013 against 0.00016.
Entered for the defence · Fitterer et al., Proceedings of ACL, Student Research Workshop, 2025 · third-party study
49.9%
of new articles primarily AI-generated, Q1 2026
"Since Q1 2025 the percentage of primarily AI-generated articles has plateaued at roughly 50%." Vendor study, detector-based.
Entered for the defence · Paredes et al., Graphite research (Five Percent), 2026 · third-party study
8.1%
rise in novelty with up to five AI ideas
Usefulness rose 9.0%. Less creative writers gained most: 10 to 11% on creativity, 22 to 26% on how enjoyable and well written the story is.
Entered for the defence · Doshi and Hauser, Science Advances, 2024 · third-party study
61.3%
average false-positive rate on 91 human TOEFL essays
Seven widely used detectors, 2023. At least one flagged 97.8% of the essays; all seven agreed on 19.8%. US eighth-grade essays were classified accurately.
Entered for the defence · Liang et al., Patterns 4(7), 2023 · third-party study
61.3% → 11.6%
average false-positive rate after ChatGPT enriched the vocabulary
Detectors read predictable wording as machine-made, so plain human writing is penalised.
Entered for the defence · Liang et al., Patterns 4(7), 2023 · third-party study
86%
of articles ranking in Google Search written by humans, June 2025
31,493 keywords across 10 categories. Only 7% of number-one results were AI-generated. Vendor study, detector-based.
Entered for the defence · Paredes et al., Graphite research (Five Percent), 2025 · third-party study
82%
of articles cited by ChatGPT, and by Perplexity, written by humans
18% AI-generated. Surfer's detector, with a false-positive rate Graphite measured at 4.2%.
Entered for the defence · Paredes et al., Graphite research (Five Percent), 2025 · third-party study
7.7%
of mathematics abstract sentences LLM-modified, September 2024
4.1% for introductions. The Nature portfolio reached 8.9% and 9.4%.
Entered for the defence · Liang et al., Nature Human Behaviour 9(12), 2025 · third-party study
35%
below expected use of "delve" across all podcast categories, after mid-2024
15% below in Science and Technology, 30% below in Business. The turn coincides with the free release of GPT-4o and public awareness of "delve" as a sign of AI.
Entered for the defence · Yakura et al., arXiv preprint (version 4, July 2026), 2026 · third-party study
2.5%
of new pages "pure AI", April 2025
25.8% "pure human". Another 9.87% showed minimal AI use (1 to 10% of the page) and 25.86% moderate use (11 to 40%).
Entered for the defence · Law et al., Ahrefs blog, 2025 · third-party study
97%
of the rise came in 2025, more than two years after ChatGPT's release
About 97%. No upward step at the cut-off: 0.1047 per 1,000 characters in 2023, 0.1157 in 2024. 2025 also brought a new Congress, and the author calls the LLM reading exploratory.
Entered for the defence · Czuma, arXiv preprint (preregistered on OSF), 2026 · third-party study
§ IIIThe docket
Every case is a real study: our own, with its method and data published on ScriptGrain, or a third-party study, credited to its authors and linked to the original. The record grows one case at a time. The full docket
§ IVA note for the record
Dead Writing Theory is a nod to the Dead Internet Theory: the idea that much of the web is now made by machines, for machines. We take the narrower, measurable corner of it, the writing: prose, copy, advertising and marketing.
§ VSubmit evidence
If you spot dead writing out in the wild, a homepage that sounds like every other homepage, a launch email that could be anyone's, send it our way. The address is hello@deadwritingtheory.com. Bring evidence. We'll take notes.